It Can't Be Wrong Dick Haymes (#1 in 1943) - words by Kim Gannon, music by Max Steiner - originally written as background music for the film "Now, Voyager" starring Bette Davis and Paul Henreid. Lyrics added well after the film's release. Wrong Would it be wrong to kiss Seeing I feel like this Would it be wrong to try? Wrong Would it be wrong to stay Here in your arms this way Under this starry sky? If it is wrong Then why were you sent to me Why am I content to be With you forever? So When I need you so much And I have waited so long It must be right It can't be wrong